Ink Or Paint First? The Great Art Debate

is it better to ink drawing first or paint

Whether you choose to ink or paint first depends on the style you want to achieve and your personal preference. Inking first gives you more control over your painting, as you can simply paint within the inked lines. This method is great if you want to achieve a tidier style with paint that stays within the lines. On the other hand, painting first can feel more freeing, as you can allow the paint to flow more freely without being restricted by borders. This method suits artists who prefer a messier, more daring style.

Characteristics Values
Advantages of inking first Watercolour is transparent, so it's easy to paint over ink drawings. Ink provides a guideline for where the paint should go, allowing for accurate painting.
Disadvantages of inking first Painting over lines may cause the ink to look faded, especially if using semi-opaque or opaque paints.
Advantages of painting first Feels more freeing as you can allow paint to flow freely without being restricted by borders. Can get interesting bleeds with wet techniques, leading to a softer, blurrier feeling.
Disadvantages of painting first May be uncomfortable for those who aren't confident with painting freehand.
Other considerations Using waterproof ink prevents bleeding. Ink drawings can be stressful due to the unforgiving permanence of ink. Drawing in pencil first can reduce pressure.

cypaint

Ink first: pros and cons

Starting with ink can be a great way to create a tidy painting with accurate lines. The ink layer acts as a guideline for where the paint should go, allowing for very accurate painting as you can simply paint within the inked lines. This method is especially suitable for artists who are not comfortable with painting freehand as the ink lines can offer a greater sense of security.

However, one downside of inking first is that it can be more challenging to plan out your painting with a lot of accuracy, especially if you don't have prior practice or use a pencil with water-soluble lead to sketch out your lines. Additionally, if you are using semi-opaque or opaque paints, painting over your inked lines might cause the ink to have a faded look. Similarly, using a very saturated layer of paint may also make the ink appear less dark.

Another consideration is the permanence of ink, which can be stressful for some artists. Ink drawings require close observation and commitment as the lines are permanent and cannot be easily erased like pencil marks. This pressure to create perfect lines can be intimidating for some artists, but it can also be liberating as it encourages a focus on capturing the scene with more life and energy rather than perfection.

To mitigate the challenges of inking first, it is recommended to use waterproof ink to prevent the ink from bleeding and to wait for the ink to dry completely before painting on top. Additionally, starting with a lighter-coloured ink or using a pencil sketch underneath can provide a guide for your final lines while reducing the pressure of creating perfect lines from the start.

cypaint

Paint first: pros and cons

Painting first can feel more freeing as you can lay your paints and let them flow without being restricted by borders. This method can also produce interesting bleeds, especially if you're using wet techniques, which can lead to a softer, blurrier feeling.

However, if you're not comfortable with painting freehand, this method may be less appealing, as the ink lines you draw after painting might offer a greater sense of security. Additionally, painting first may make it more difficult to plan out your drawing with a lot of accuracy, unless you're confident working without guidelines or use a pencil with water-soluble lead to sketch out your lines first.

Another downside to painting first is that, if you plan to ink over your paint, you'll need to ensure your paint is completely dry before adding ink, or the ink may bleed. Moreover, if you're using semi-opaque or opaque paint, painting over your lines might cause the ink to appear faded, and a very saturated layer of paint may make the ink look less dark.

If you choose to paint with ink, you'll need to select the right type of ink for your purposes. For instance, if you want to paint over your ink drawings, you'll need to use waterproof ink to prevent the ink from bleeding. On the other hand, if you want to be able to reactivate your ink, you might choose a dye-based ink that isn't water-resistant, such as Winsor & Newton Calligraphy Ink.

Overall, painting first can be a great way to embrace a more carefree and expressive style, but it may not be the best choice if you're seeking a tidier look or if you prefer the security of having guidelines to follow.

cypaint

Waterproof ink and watercolour

When it comes to creating art with waterproof ink and watercolour, there are a few things to consider in terms of technique, materials, and personal preference.

Firstly, it's important to choose the right ink and paper. Opt for a waterproof ink to prevent bleeding and ensure crisp outlines. Inks labelled as pigmented are often waterproof, as these particles don't dissolve in water. However, always test new inks on your specific paper to ensure they are compatible and don't smudge. Fast-drying inks can help minimise smudging, and some sources recommend waiting up to 12 or 24 hours before applying watercolour over ink.

Regarding technique, some artists prefer to ink first, providing a guideline for where the paint should go and allowing for accurate painting within the lines. Watercolour's transparency also makes it suitable for use over ink, as the darker ink layer will show through. However, painting over the lines may cause the ink to look faded, especially with opaque paints or very saturated layers.

On the other hand, painting first can feel more freeing, as you're not restricted to painting within borders. This method can also produce interesting bleeds and softer, blurrier effects. If you're uncomfortable with painting freehand, inking first may offer more security.

Ultimately, the decision to ink or paint first depends on your personal preference and the style you wish to achieve. Trying out different methods can help expand your artistic skills and allow you to discover what works best for you.

Some recommended products for waterproof ink and watercolour art include the Uni-Ball Signo gel pen, Sakura's Pigma Micron series, Parker fountain pens, Tombow Fudenosuke brush pen, Copic Multiliner Pens, and Speedball Super Black India Ink.

Rust-Oleum Glow Paint: Does It Work?

You may want to see also

cypaint

Ink wash techniques

Ink wash painting is a process that involves using black India ink to create greyscale works of art. This technique is similar to watercolour painting, and many watercolour techniques like wet on wet produce similar results with ink wash. However, one significant difference is that ink wash is less forgiving, and mistakes made are challenging to rectify. Ink wash is also best applied in layers, from light to dark, allowing each layer to dry before adding a new one.

  • Start with a pencil sketch: Before diving into ink wash painting, it's helpful to begin with a light pencil sketch to outline the image you want to paint. This provides a guideline and allows you to focus on shades and shadows.
  • Prepare your palette: Experiment with colour gradation by creating a gradient palette. Mix different amounts of water with your ink to achieve various shades, ranging from pure black to light grey.
  • Cross-hatching: Cross-hatching is a technique that involves drawing small, straight lines to create shading and add dimension to your painting.
  • Stipple and splatter: Create depth in your painting by making small dots or "stipple." For a messier but fun effect, load your brush with ink and tap it with your finger to create "splatter."
  • Bleeds: Play with water and ink to create interesting bleeds. Saturate an area of your paper with water, then dip your brush in ink and dab it onto the wet area, watching the ink bleed and move.
  • Line variation: India ink allows you to create different line thicknesses and darkness within a single stroke by adjusting the pressure you apply. Practice making lines with varying pressure to achieve the desired effect.
  • Brushes and paper: The type of brush and paper you use can significantly impact your ink wash painting. Traditional ink wash uses a special brush called a sumi brush, while mould-made 100% cotton watercolour paper is recommended for its ability to absorb ink without warping.

Ink wash painting is an art-making technique that combines drawing and painting. By experimenting with different techniques and tools, you can create unique and expressive works of art.

cypaint

Ink drawing techniques

Whether you choose to ink your drawing first or paint depends on your personal preference and comfort level with different tools. Painting first can feel more freeing as you can allow your paints to flow more freely without being restricted by borders. On the other hand, inking first provides a guideline for where the paint should go, allowing for more accurate painting within the inked lines.

Now, let's delve into some ink drawing techniques to enhance your creations:

Hatching and Cross-Hatching:

Hatching is a fundamental technique in ink drawing, where lines are drawn in the same direction within a defined area to add value in a linear fashion. The lines in hatching do not cross over each other, and they can be parallel or used as cross-contour lines to define the form of the object. Cross-hatching, on the other hand, involves lines crossing over each other, allowing for greater control over the range of values produced. The frequency of line crossing will determine the darkness of the value.

Creating Gradations in Value:

When using high-contrast black ink on white paper, you can create the illusion of gradations in value by varying the thickness of your lines. Use thicker lines for structures in shadows and thinner lines for areas in the light. This technique adds volume and depth to your drawings.

Playing with Tones:

Experiment with tones by rubbing a bit of water onto your fresh ink lines to create softer tones. You can also try using pens that are dried up, as they can deliver a dry, brush-like stroke with a unique look.

Holding the Pen:

Changing the way you hold your pen can add an unexpected dimension to your drawings. Try holding the pen at the back for looser lines that can present unique opportunities and happy accidents in your work.

Paper Choice:

The type of paper you choose can also impact your ink drawings. For high-quality results, consider using Hahnemule's Lettering pads, which offer thin paper that doesn't bleed. If you're looking for a professional finish, opt for a smooth illustration board.

Remember, the key to mastering ink drawing techniques is practice. So, grab your favourite pen and ink and explore the endless possibilities that this medium has to offer!

Frequently asked questions

Inking first gives you more control over your work, as you can simply paint within the inked lines. It also helps you plan out your painting with more accuracy.

Painting first can feel more freeing, as you can allow your paints to flow more freely without the pressure of staying within the borders.

Painting over your inked lines might cause the ink to look faded, especially if your paints are opaque. It can also be more challenging to plan out your painting with accuracy.

If you're not comfortable with painting freehand, the lack of inked lines might make you feel insecure.

Remember that ink can be unforgiving and permanent, so it might be a good idea to sketch your ideas in pencil first. You can also experiment with different types of pens and inks to create unique effects.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment