Unveiling Secrets: Dating Paintings By Varnish

how to tell age of a painting through varnish

Determining the age of a painting is a complex process that involves examining various aspects of the artwork. One of the key indicators of a painting's age is the presence of varnish and the associated discolouration or yellowing over time. While varnish can provide valuable insights, it can also be manipulated to deceive; forgers may artificially age a painting by creating a yellow varnish to make a modern painting appear older. To verify the authenticity and age of a painting, experts employ a range of scientific techniques, including carbon-14 dating, ultraviolet imaging to reveal surface repaints, infrared reflectography to detect hidden signatures, and X-ray radiography to assess the overall state of conservation. Additionally, the examination of brush strokes, pigment samples, and the verso (the back) of the canvas can provide valuable information about the painting's age and provenance.

Characteristics Values
Discolouration A painting's surface may discolour through age or contamination.
Varnish A yellow-tinted varnish may be used to make a painting appear older.
Brush strokes An expert can examine brush strokes to determine if a painting is a copy or a forgery.
Pigment samples Conservators can take pigment samples for age analysis.
Costume The clothing worn by figures in a painting can indicate the period.
Relining A newer canvas attached to an older one to preserve it.
Craquelure Fine cracks that appear in old oil and tempera paintings over time.
Canvas The verso (back) of a canvas can provide telling information about its age.
Stamps Canvases may have supplier stamps which can be useful for ascertaining age.
Scientific analysis Carbon-14 dating, grazing light, transmitted light, ultraviolet imaging, infrared reflectography, and x-ray radiography can be used to determine the age of a painting.

cypaint

Varnish discolouration

One of the key indicators of varnish discolouration is the yellowing of the varnish film. This yellowing can be uniform or vary in intensity across the painting, creating an uneven appearance. The yellowing is often more pronounced in areas with thicker varnish applications. In some cases, the varnish may also darken, resulting in a darker and murkier appearance.

Additionally, varnish discolouration can be caused by external factors such as exposure to heat, sunlight, or pollutants in the environment. Heat and sunlight can accelerate the degradation of the varnish, causing it to discolour and darken prematurely. Pollution, such as smoke or dust, can also settle on the varnish surface and contribute to discolouration.

It is important to note that not all varnishes are created equal. Some types of varnish, such as acrylic varnish, are known for their colour stability and resistance to discolouration. However, even with these varnishes, discolouration can occur under certain conditions or if the varnish is not properly applied or cured.

In some instances, varnish discolouration can be addressed by carefully removing and replacing the varnish layer. This process, known as varnish removal or stripping, involves using chemical solvents or mechanical methods to lift the discoloured varnish and applying a fresh layer of varnish. However, varnish removal is a delicate procedure that requires expertise, as it carries the risk of damaging the underlying artwork if not performed correctly.

cypaint

Craquelure

The term craquelure is most commonly associated with tempera or oil paintings, but it can also be found in other art forms, such as ivory carvings or painted miniatures on ivory backing. The formation of craquelure is influenced by various factors, including the type of paint, medium, and the presence of additives such as organic solvents or surfactants.

Over time, oil paint begins to crack along the grain of the canvas, resulting in a fine pattern of cracks known as craquelure. These cracks can be oriented in different directions, depending on the artistic tradition and historical period. For example, Italian paintings from the 14th to 15th centuries tend to have cracks perpendicular to the wood grain, while Flemish paintings from the same period have cracks that follow the wood grain.

While craquelure can be a sign of a painting's age, it is important to note that it can also be artificially induced. Art forgers have developed techniques to create craquelure, such as using formaldehyde and a special baking process, or by employing zinc white paints as the underlayer. However, artificial craquelure tends to have uniform cracks, while genuine craquelure has irregular patterns. Additionally, the presence of dirt in the cracks of light-coloured paint layers can be a sign of disfiguration caused by craquelure.

To accurately determine the age and authenticity of a painting through craquelure analysis, it is essential to consult an expert. Conservators can examine the painting closely and compare the crack patterns with historical references to provide valuable insights into the painting's age and provenance.

cypaint

Canvas relining

The process of relining a painting is a form of conservation science and art restoration used to strengthen, flatten, or consolidate oil or tempera paintings on canvas. This process involves attaching a new support to the back of the existing one. In cases of extreme decay, the original canvas may be completely replaced.

The decision to reline a piece of art is typically made when various agents of deterioration have caused excessive damage over time. For instance, physical forces such as impacts, shocks, and abrasions can cause cracks, tears, or separate the paint from its canvas. Water damage may also result in mould formations and weaken the canvas, causing tears. Fluctuations in temperature and humidity can also cause damage, often due to improper storage and exhibition.

There is some controversy surrounding the process of relining a painting. While it can help mitigate or revert wear caused by deterioration, some argue that it is unnecessary and may cause further damage. For example, relining often results in a flattening of any raised paint (impasto). Additionally, the adhesive agents or lining materials may interact negatively with the original work.

If you are examining a painting to determine if it has been relined, you can look for clues such as stretcher/strainer bars and nails, as these are often rescued from the original canvas. You can also examine the canvas closely to see if there is more than one layer. It is important to note that forgers have been known to attach their copies to older canvases to make them appear older.

cypaint

Carbon-14 dating

In the context of paintings, carbon-14 dating is used to determine the age of the support, such as the canvas, wood, or paper, rather than the age of the painting itself. This helps to verify the chronological compatibility between the support and the period of activity of the painter. However, it is important to clean the samples and ensure they are free of contaminants, such as varnish added during later renovations, which could skew the readings.

While carbon-14 dating is a valuable tool, it has limitations. The technique is limited to organic materials, and the results typically have an accuracy range of around 80 years. Additionally, natural pigments may not provide chronological information, and the dating of pigments can be challenging. Other methods, such as dendrochronology and thermoluminescence, are also used for dating paintings and can complement carbon-14 dating.

cypaint

Ultraviolet imaging

The imaging methodology of UVF involves shining a UV lamp at an angle of around 45 degrees to the artwork being examined. A digital camera equipped with a UV filter is then used to capture the image, revealing the fluorescence. This technique is particularly useful for identifying the various layers of varnish on a painting. Varnishes are often composed of different substances, including natural resins, glues, oils, and other organic materials, and UVF can help identify their presence, overlap, and homogeneity.

Additionally, UVF can be used to detect retouching or overpainting on top of an aged varnish. Oil paint and newer varnish do not fluoresce under UV light, appearing as dark patches on the surface. Certain pigments and binders fluoresce in distinct colours under UV light, aiding in the identification of original artistic methods and any subsequent restorations.

While UVF is a valuable tool, it is not always conclusive on its own. Some materials may not fluoresce, and older retouches or forgeries may be indistinguishable from the original painting. Furthermore, the fluorescence of varnishes can sometimes impede the observation of underlying layers. Therefore, UVF is often used in conjunction with other investigative techniques, such as carbon-14 dating and infrared reflectography, to comprehensively characterise a painting's history and authenticity.

Frequently asked questions

If a painting has been heavily varnished, it can be harder to spot signs of ageing. However, over time, varnish can discolour and turn yellow, which can be a sign of ageing. Some modern paintings have been artificially aged by adding a yellow varnish.

The verso (the back) of a canvas can provide telling information about its age. For example, most 17th-century paintings are relined, which means a newer canvas has been attached to the back of an older one to preserve it. The stretcher bars on these paintings are very roughly hand-cut and often contain original hand-wrought nails. An 18th-century canvas back will likely be darker and the stretcher bars will be more rudimentary. Many 19th-century canvases have been relined as well. Additionally, the canvas itself can be carbon-14 dated to verify the chronological compatibility between the support and the period of the painter's activity.

The clothing and costume of the figures in a painting can indicate the period in which it was painted. Additionally, the painting's frame can be indicative of its age. For example, the frame of a painting can be compared to those of other pieces in museums that have been dated.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment