Reviving Polyurethane: Fixing Yellowing Over Faux Marble Paint

Polyurethane is a popular choice for sealing surfaces, but it can sometimes discolour, turning a yellow hue. This is more common with oil-based polyurethanes, which can start to yellow within 6 months to 2 years, whereas water-based polyurethanes may take up to 3 years to show signs of discolouration. There are a few methods to fix yellowed polyurethane, including stripping and sanding the surface, before refinishing with a new coat of paint or polyurethane. However, it's important to note that once polyurethane has cured, nothing will stick to it, so stripping and sanding may be necessary to achieve the best finish. To prevent yellowing, it is recommended to use a self-sealing paint or a high-quality polyurethane designed for painted surfaces.

How to fix yellowed polyurethane over faux marble paint

Use water-based polyurethane to avoid yellowing

Polyurethane is a popular choice for finishing and protecting surfaces, but it can sometimes cause unwanted yellowing, especially when used over light-coloured paint. Oil-based polyurethanes are known to yellow over time, especially when exposed to UV rays from sunlight. This can give your project a yellowish or amber tint that may not be desirable, especially if you're aiming for a clear or light finish.

To avoid yellowing, it is recommended to use a water-based polyurethane. Water-based polyurethanes are less likely to yellow and can provide a clearer, more transparent finish. They are a better choice if you want to maintain the original colour and appearance of your project. Water-based polyurethanes, such as Bona Traffic HD and Loba, are formulated to resist yellowing and offer UV protection, ensuring that your project stays looking its best.

While water-based polyurethanes may require more coats compared to oil-based ones to achieve a durable finish, they are worth the extra effort if you want to avoid yellowing. It is also important to note that not all water-based polyurethanes are created equal; cheaper brands may still exhibit some yellowing over time. Therefore, it is essential to invest in high-quality water-borne polyurethane to ensure the best results and minimise the risk of yellowing.

Additionally, proper application techniques play a vital role in preventing yellowing. It is crucial to allow the stain or paint to dry thoroughly before applying the polyurethane. Applying polyurethane too quickly can cause issues, as evident in some users' experiences. Thin coats are preferable to thick ones, as thick coats can lead to yellowing. Sanding between coats is also recommended for a smooth and even finish.

By choosing a high-quality water-based polyurethane, applying it thinly and allowing adequate drying time between coats, you can effectively avoid the yellowing issue and achieve the desired finish for your project.

Sand off the polyurethane sheen and repaint

If you want to fix yellowed polyurethane over faux marble paint, one option is to sand off the polyurethane sheen and then repaint. Polyurethane is only a few thousandths of an inch thick, so it is possible to sand it off without damaging the paint underneath. However, it is important to be careful and not sand too deeply, as you could end up removing the paint as well.

Before you start sanding, it is important to choose the right sandpaper grit for the job. The grit number refers to the number of abrasive particles per square inch on the sandpaper, so a lower grit number means a coarser sandpaper. For initial sanding, you may want to start with a lower grit number, such as 80 or 120, and then move to a finer grit, such as 180 or 220, as you get closer to the paint. When sanding the topcoat, it is recommended to use 180 to 220 grit sandpaper.

It is also important to use the correct technique when sanding. Wipe the polyurethane with a cloth or rag, rather than flooding it with a brush, to avoid puddling. Sand with the grain of the wood and be careful not to apply too much pressure, as this can cause uneven results. If you are having trouble sanding without removing the paint, you can try using a lighter touch or a finer grit sandpaper.

Once you have sanded off the polyurethane sheen, you can repaint the surface. It is important to choose a paint that is compatible with the surface and your desired finish. For example, if you are looking for a clear finish, it is best to use a water-based paint, as oil-based paints tend to yellow over time. You may also need to prime the surface before painting, especially if you are using a water-based paint on a surface that was previously painted with oil-based paint.

After repainting, you may need to apply a new topcoat of polyurethane to protect the surface. If you do, be sure to choose a clear coat that is compatible with your paint and follow the instructions carefully to avoid yellowing.

Use a chemical stripper to remove polyurethane

To fix yellowed polyurethane over faux marble paint, you can use a chemical stripper to remove the polyurethane. It is essential to determine whether the polyurethane is water-based or oil-based. Chemical solvents are the fastest, easiest, and most inexpensive way to strip polyurethane. However, they are hazardous materials, and proper precautions must be taken.

Before using a chemical stripper, ensure you are working in a well-ventilated area or outdoors. Open all doors and windows and set up a fan to create cross-ventilation. Put on protective gear, including rubber gloves, goggles, and a respirator mask, to safeguard against chemical fumes and splashes. Cover the floor with a plastic tarp or a protective layer to prevent damage to the surface.

To start the stripping process, brush a generous amount of the chemical stripper onto the polyurethane. Allow the solvent to soak in for approximately 10 minutes. Then, use a metal scraper, steel brush, or putty knife to scrape away the softened polyurethane. If necessary, let the solvent sit for a longer duration to ensure the polyurethane is adequately softened.

After removing the bulk of the polyurethane, wipe the surface with afterwash or mineral spirits to eliminate any remaining residue. Finish the process by sanding the surface with fine steel wool or sandpaper to achieve the desired smoothness. Remember to dispose of the discarded rags, steel wool, and leftover stripper safely by taking them to a hazardous waste disposal unit.

Prevent yellowing with a UV-resistant sealer

Preventing yellowing on polyurethane-coated surfaces is possible with the use of a UV-resistant sealer. Polyurethane, especially oil-based polyurethane, is known to yellow over time due to exposure to sunlight and UV rays. To avoid this, it is recommended to opt for water-based polyurethane as it yellows much less.

UV-resistant sealers are designed to protect surfaces from the damaging effects of UV light, thereby preventing discolouration. One such sealer is the PolyWhey® SunSeal Anti-Yellowing UV Protection by Vermont Natural Coatings. This sealer is made with natural whey protein and provides professional-strength UV protection for interior bare wood floors. It is easy to apply, dries quickly, and helps maintain the natural beauty of the wood.

Another option is to use an acrylic finish, as acrylic holds its clear colour better than other coatings. Specifically, Sherwin-Williams acrylic lacquer with a vinyl sealer has been recommended by a user, who has had no issues with yellowing over a seven-year period. This combination is especially effective for paint-grade white, which is known to be challenging to prevent from yellowing.

Additionally, Guardsman/Lilly coatings are said to have a special UV block that is non-sacrificial, meaning it does not lose its UV-blocking qualities over time. While these coatings have been reported to be effective, it is worth noting that some experts remain cautious about guaranteeing that wood will never change colour.

By selecting the appropriate UV-resistant sealer and following the recommended application procedures, you can effectively prevent yellowing on polyurethane-coated surfaces and maintain their desired appearance.

Use a self-sealing paint that doesn't need a topcoat

If you are looking to fix yellowed polyurethane over faux marble paint, one option is to use a self-sealing paint that does not require a topcoat. While sealing painted furniture is generally recommended to protect the finish and ensure durability, there are certain types of paint that do not require this additional step.

One such type of paint is Valspar's oil-enriched enamel. According to a DIYer who works at Valspar, this paint dries very hard, and due to its oil-enriched formula, it is likely safe to skip the topcoat. However, it is important to note that this is just one opinion, and you may want to seek additional advice before proceeding.

Another option for a self-sealing paint is chalk paint. While chalk paint adheres well to various surfaces and has a beautiful matte finish, it is not very durable. Therefore, it is recommended to protect the finish with a sealer or topcoat to prevent scratching and staining.

If you choose to use a self-sealing paint, it is important to follow the manufacturer's instructions and recommendations for application and curing time. Additionally, consider the intended use of the painted surface. For example, if it will be used in a high-traffic area, it is generally advisable to use a sealer for added protection.

By opting for a self-sealing paint, you can streamline the refinishing process and avoid the need for additional steps such as sanding, priming, and applying a separate topcoat. This can save you time and effort while still achieving a desirable finish.

Frequently asked questions