Benjamin Moore Vs. Sherwin Williams: Premium Paint, Premium Price?

is benjamin moore paint more expensive than sherwin williams

Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams are two of the biggest brands in the painting industry, with both companies offering high-quality paints. While both brands offer low to high-quality exterior paints, Benjamin Moore is often recognised as having a slightly better quality than Sherwin Williams. However, Sherwin Williams is known for its low-cost options and wide range of colours. So, which paint is more expensive?

Characteristics Values
Quality Both brands offer low to high-quality paints. Benjamin Moore is often considered to have a slightly better quality than Sherwin Williams.
Coverage Benjamin Moore paints tend to have better coverage and require fewer coats.
Colour options Benjamin Moore has almost 2000 more colour options than Sherwin Williams.
Technology Both brands have developed stain-resistant technology. Benjamin Moore has Gennex Color Technology and Color Lock Technology, while Sherwin Williams uses Ceramic Microspheres and Proprietary Resin Technology.
Durability Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint is more durable than Sherwin Williams' ProClassic Waterborne Interior Acrylic Enamel. Sherwin Williams' Duration and Emerald paints are more expensive than SuperPaint but offer superior durability.
Price Sherwin Williams' SuperPaint is considered more affordable than Benjamin Moore's Aura paint line. Sherwin Williams' ProClassic Waterborne Interior Acrylic Enamel is priced at $70-$80 per gallon, while Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint is $15-$20 cheaper.
Ease of use Sherwin Williams' SuperPaint is self-priming and easy to clean. Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint is low odour and can be applied by brush, roll, or spray. However, it dries slowly and requires two coats for proper coverage.
Availability Sherwin Williams stores are corporate-owned, while Benjamin Moore stores are locally owned.

cypaint

Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint is more expensive than Sherwin Williams' ProClassic

When it comes to painting, Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams are two of the leading brands, each with its own loyal following. While both companies produce high-quality paints, there are some differences between their products that may influence your decision.

Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint is a water-based product designed for use on trim. It delivers a smooth, high-quality finish that is resistant to cracking and peeling. The paint is low odour and easy to clean up, and it can be applied by brush, roller, or spray. However, one of the drawbacks of Advance Trim Paint is that it is more expensive than other types of paint, including Sherwin Williams' ProClassic. Advance Trim Paint also requires two coats for proper coverage and dries slowly.

On the other hand, Sherwin Williams' ProClassic paint is a popular choice for interior trim. It is a low-VOC paint, which means it gives off fewer volatile organic compounds than other paints. ProClassic has a smooth, even finish, but it is not very resistant to stains or moisture. While ProClassic paint is also considered pricey, it typically costs more than Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint, ranging from $40 to $90 per gallon, with some sources giving a narrower range of $70-$80 per gallon.

In terms of overall brand comparison, Benjamin Moore paint is generally considered to be slightly more expensive than Sherwin Williams when similar products are compared. For example, Benjamin Moore's Aura paint line is $15-$25 more expensive per gallon than Sherwin Williams' SuperPaint, which offers comparable quality. Similarly, Sherwin Williams' Emerald line is priced between $81.42 and $93.99, while the comparable Aura line from Benjamin Moore is priced at $80 per gallon.

However, it is important to note that the choice between the two brands often comes down to personal preference, project specifics, and whether supporting local businesses is a priority. Benjamin Moore stores are locally owned, while Sherwin Williams stores are corporate-owned. Both brands offer high-quality paints with unique strengths, and neither brand is considered to be superior to the other.

cypaint

Benjamin Moore's Aura paint is $15-$25 more expensive than Regal Select

Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are two of the leading paint brands, each with its own unique strengths and loyal following. While both brands offer high-quality paints, there are some differences in their products and pricing.

When it comes to Benjamin Moore's Aura paint line, it is a step above the Regal Select line. Aura paint is VOC-free or low-VOC, and it offers thicker coverage that better hides the colour beneath. The Aura line also features Benjamin Moore's Gennex Color Technology, which reduces volatile organic compounds and allows the paint to retain more vibrant hues that last longer. Due to these features, Benjamin Moore's Aura paint is $15-$25 more expensive per gallon than the Regal Select line.

The Ben paint line by Benjamin Moore is another option that is worth considering. Ben is $20 cheaper per gallon than Regal Select while still offering better performance than entry-level interior paints from Sherwin-Williams, such as A-100. However, Regal Select provides superior coverage and thickness compared to Ben.

Sherwin-Williams also has its premium paint lines, such as Duration and Emerald, which are $20-$30 more expensive than their SuperPaint line. These premium latex paints offer superior durability and longevity, lasting 8-10 years on average. They are thicker paints that require a higher level of skill to apply.

In terms of trim paint, Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint is a water-based product that delivers a high-quality, factory-like finish that is resistant to cracking and peeling. It has low odour, easy cleanup, and can be applied by brush, roll, or spray. However, it is more expensive than other types of paint and requires two coats for proper coverage. Sherwin-Williams' ProClassic Waterborne Interior Acrylic Enamel is a comparable option, curing quicker than Advance Trim Paint but costing $15-$20 more per gallon.

Ultimately, the choice between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams depends on various factors, including personal preference, project specifics, and support for local businesses, as Benjamin Moore stores are locally owned while Sherwin-Williams stores are corporate-owned.

cypaint

Sherwin Williams' SuperPaint is $20 cheaper per gallon than Benjamin Moore's Aura

Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams are two of the leading paint brands, each with its own unique strengths and loyal following. While both brands offer high-quality paints, with minor differences that only professionals might notice, there are some distinctions between their products that are worth noting.

Sherwin Williams' SuperPaint is a popular choice for painting projects due to its low price and wide range of colours. It is self-priming, durable, easy to clean, and DIY-friendly. SuperPaint is also low-VOC, which means it has fewer volatile organic compounds, reducing its environmental impact. At $20 less per gallon than Benjamin Moore's Aura paint, SuperPaint offers excellent value for money without compromising on quality.

On the other hand, Benjamin Moore's Aura paint line is VOC-free or low-VOC, ensuring better air quality during and after painting. Aura paint is thicker, providing better coverage and requiring fewer coats to achieve the desired finish. It also features Benjamin Moore's Gennex Color Technology, which eliminates chemicals that cause dark colours to weaken the paint, allowing it to retain more vibrant hues that last longer. While Aura paint is more expensive than SuperPaint, it may be worth the investment for those seeking superior coverage and long-lasting colour retention.

Ultimately, the choice between Sherwin Williams' SuperPaint and Benjamin Moore's Aura depends on individual needs and preferences. SuperPaint offers a cost-effective option with good coverage and durability, while Aura provides thicker paint, improved colour retention, and lower VOC levels. Considering the specific requirements of your painting project, as well as your budget, will help guide your decision in selecting the most suitable paint for your needs.

It is worth noting that both brands offer a range of products, and there may be other factors beyond cost and coverage that influence your decision, such as colour options, finish, durability, and environmental considerations. Additionally, personal preferences and project specifics can also play a role in choosing the right paint brand for your home or project.

Stopping Paint Shop Pro Pop-Up Ads

You may want to see also

cypaint

Sherwin Williams' Duration and Emerald paints are $20-$30 more expensive than SuperPaint

Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are two of the leading brands in the world of paint, with each brand having its own unique strengths and loyal following. While the choice between the two often comes down to personal preference and project specifics, there are some differences in their product lines.

Sherwin-Williams' SuperPaint is a popular choice for painting projects due to its low price and wide range of colours. It is self-priming, durable, easy to clean, and DIY-friendly. At around $47 to $48 per gallon, SuperPaint offers excellent value for money, delivering high quality at a reasonable price.

Sherwin-Williams Duration and Emerald paints are positioned as premium offerings within the brand's portfolio. Duration is priced between $70 and $75 per can, while Emerald costs nearly $70 per gallon. These paints are $20-$30 more expensive than SuperPaint, offering superior durability and longevity. They are thicker paints that require a higher skill level to apply and are recommended for older homes with a lot of wood and previous coats. Duration, in particular, is known for its ability to withstand rigorous testing circumstances, making it a suitable choice for hallways and other high-traffic areas.

While Benjamin Moore's paint products are generally more expensive than Sherwin-Williams, with an average gallon costing $57 compared to Sherwin-Williams' $53, there are instances where Benjamin Moore offers more competitive pricing. For example, Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint, which is designed for use on trim, is about $15-$20 cheaper per gallon than Sherwin-Williams' comparable product, ProClassic Waterborne Interior Acrylic Enamel. Additionally, Benjamin Moore's Ben paint is $20 per gallon cheaper than Sherwin-Williams' Regal Select, while offering better performance than Sherwin-Williams' entry-level interior paints.

cypaint

Benjamin Moore has almost 2000 more colour options than Sherwin Williams

Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams are two of the biggest brands of paint in the world, with both brands offering high-quality products. However, there are some differences between the two. Benjamin Moore's paint tends to have better coverage, requiring fewer coats to achieve a desired finish. Additionally, Benjamin Moore has almost 2000 more colour options than Sherwin Williams.

When it comes to cost, it depends on the specific product line being compared. For example, Benjamin Moore's Aura paint line is $15-$25 more expensive than its Regal Select line, while Sherwin Williams' SuperPaint is $20 less per gallon than Benjamin Moore's Aura paint. Similarly, Sherwin Williams' ProClassic Waterborne Interior Acrylic Enamel is priced at $70-$80 per gallon, while Benjamin Moore's comparable Advance Trim Paint is $15-$20 cheaper per gallon.

Both brands have their own exclusive technology, usually found in their higher-quality products. Benjamin Moore's Gennex Color Technology and Color Lock Technology focus on maintaining deep and accurate pigments, resulting in colours that last longer and are more resistant to fading. On the other hand, Sherwin Williams' Ceramic Microspheres and Proprietary Resin Technology improve paint durability, resistance to stains, and insulation.

Ultimately, the choice between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams comes down to personal preference, project specifics, and whether supporting local businesses is a priority, as Benjamin Moore stores are locally owned while Sherwin Williams stores are corporate-owned.

Frequently asked questions

It depends on the product line. Some Sherwin Williams paints, like SuperPaint, are $20 cheaper per gallon than Benjamin Moore's Aura and Regal Select. However, Benjamin Moore's Advance Trim Paint is $15-$20 cheaper per gallon than Sherwin Williams' ProClassic Waterborne Interior Acrylic Enamel.

Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams offer high-quality paints, with minor differences in product lines. Benjamin Moore paints tend to have better coverage with fewer coats needed to achieve the desired finish and have almost 2,000 more colour options than Sherwin Williams. However, Sherwin Williams' paints are self-priming, easy to clean, and DIY-friendly.

The choice between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams depends on your personal preference, project specifics, and whether supporting local businesses is a priority. Benjamin Moore stores are locally owned, while Sherwin Williams stores are corporate-owned.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment