War Paint's Broadway Run: A Critical And Commercial Analysis

how is war paint doing on broadway

War Paint, the captivating Broadway musical that chronicles the rivalry and rise of cosmetics titans Helena Rubinstein and Elizabeth Arden, has left a lasting impression on audiences and critics alike since its debut. With a stellar book by Doug Wright, a lush score by Scott Frankel and Michael Korie, and powerhouse performances by its leading ladies, the show offers a glamorous yet poignant exploration of ambition, innovation, and the complexities of female entrepreneurship in the early 20th century. While its initial run concluded in 2017, War Paint continues to resonate through regional productions and its enduring themes, solidifying its place as a standout in Broadway’s recent history. Its portrayal of two pioneering women in a male-dominated industry remains both timely and inspiring, ensuring its legacy endures beyond the Great White Way.

Characteristics Values
Current Status Closed (Final performance: November 5, 2017)
Original Broadway Production Run March 18, 2017 - November 5, 2017
Number of Performances 299 performances and 26 previews
Theater Nederlander Theatre
Book Doug Wright
Music & Lyrics Scott Frankel (music), Michael Korie (lyrics)
Direction Michael Greif
Choreography Christopher Gattelli
Original Cast Patti LuPone (Helena Rubinstein), Christine Ebersole (Elizabeth Arden)
Tony Awards 4 nominations (including Best Musical, Best Actress in a Musical for both LuPone and Ebersole), 0 wins
Critical Reception Generally positive reviews, praised for performances and production values
Box Office Performance Moderate success, struggled to meet potential despite strong reviews
Legacy Remembered for its strong female leads and exploration of female rivalry in the beauty industry

cypaint

Box Office Performance: Analyzing ticket sales, revenue trends, and audience attendance figures for War Paint on Broadway

War Paint, the Broadway musical that tells the story of the rivalry between beauty titans Helena Rubinstein and Elizabeth Arden, opened to mixed reviews but has shown a steady, if not spectacular, performance at the box office. Since its debut, the show has consistently maintained a respectable position in weekly Broadway gross reports, often hovering around the $500,000 to $700,000 mark. While these figures are not groundbreaking, they indicate a stable audience interest, particularly among niche demographics drawn to its historical and feminist themes. Ticket sales have been bolstered by the star power of its leads and the allure of its opulent set design, which has been a significant draw for theatergoers seeking a visually stunning experience.

Revenue trends for War Paint reveal a pattern of gradual growth during its initial months, followed by a plateau as the novelty wore off. The musical benefited from strong holiday season sales, a common trend for Broadway shows, but struggled to maintain momentum during slower periods. Discounting strategies, such as offering reduced-price tickets through platforms like TodayTix and TKTS, have been employed to fill seats, which has helped stabilize revenue but also impacted overall gross earnings. Despite this, the show’s premium ticket pricing, particularly for orchestra seats, has contributed to a healthier bottom line compared to other mid-tier productions.

Audience attendance figures for War Paint have been consistent but unspectacular, reflecting the show’s niche appeal. While it has not sold out consistently, the musical has maintained an average attendance rate of 70-80% of its theater’s capacity. This is a solid performance, especially considering the competitive Broadway landscape. The audience demographic skews older, with a significant portion of attendees being women over 40, likely drawn to the show’s themes of female empowerment and historical drama. Efforts to broaden its appeal, such as targeted marketing campaigns and educational outreach, have shown modest success in attracting younger and more diverse audiences.

A closer analysis of ticket sales data reveals that War Paint has performed best during weeks with special promotions or celebrity appearances. For instance, weeks featuring post-show talks with the creative team or limited-time discounts saw spikes in ticket sales, highlighting the importance of strategic marketing in sustaining audience interest. Additionally, the show’s performance has been influenced by external factors, such as weather conditions and competing events in New York City, which have occasionally impacted attendance. Despite these fluctuations, War Paint has demonstrated resilience, maintaining a steady presence in a market dominated by long-running hits and high-profile new productions.

In comparison to other Broadway shows in its category, War Paint’s box office performance can be described as middle-of-the-road. It has outperformed some smaller-scale productions but has not reached the heights of blockbuster musicals. Its revenue and attendance figures suggest that while it may not be a record-breaker, it has carved out a stable niche for itself. The show’s ability to sustain its run without significant dips in performance is a testament to its strong production values and the enduring appeal of its subject matter. As it continues its Broadway run, War Paint’s box office trajectory will likely depend on its ability to innovate in marketing and audience engagement strategies.

cypaint

Critical Reception: Reviewing professional critiques, awards, and overall reception from theater critics

War Paint, the Broadway musical that chronicles the rivalry between cosmetics titans Helena Rubinstein and Elizabeth Arden, received a mixed but generally positive reception from theater critics upon its 2017 debut. The show, starring Patti LuPone as Rubinstein and Christine Ebersole as Arden, was praised for its powerhouse performances and lavish production design. The New York Times lauded the leading actresses, noting that their "fierce, nuanced portrayals" elevated the material, even if the script occasionally faltered. Critics often highlighted the chemistry between LuPone and Ebersole as the production's saving grace, with their dueling presence dominating the stage and anchoring the narrative.

Awards-wise, *War Paint* garnered several nominations but fell short of major wins. The production received four Tony Award nominations, including Best Actress in a Musical for both LuPone and Ebersole, but ultimately went home empty-handed. Despite this, the show was recognized for its technical achievements, particularly its costume and scenic design, which captured the opulence of mid-20th-century New York. The Drama Desk Awards also acknowledged the performances of the leading actresses, further cementing their roles as the standout elements of the production.

Theater critics were divided on the musical's book and score. While some praised the lyrics by Doug Wright for their wit and insight into the lives of these pioneering women, others found the storytelling uneven and the music by Scott Frankel and Michael Korie forgettable. Variety described the score as "serviceable but not groundbreaking," noting that it failed to match the emotional depth of the characters. Similarly, the plot was criticized for its slow pacing and lack of dramatic tension, with some reviewers suggesting that the rivalry between Rubinstein and Arden was not fully exploited for its dramatic potential.

Despite these criticisms, *War Paint* was appreciated for its thematic relevance, particularly its exploration of female ambition, aging, and the cost of success in a male-dominated industry. The Hollywood Reporter commended the musical for shedding light on the untold stories of these two iconic women, calling it a "timely and necessary addition to Broadway's roster." The production's feminist undertones resonated with many critics, who viewed it as a celebration of women's resilience and innovation.

Overall, *War Paint* was a polarizing entry in the 2017 Broadway season. While it failed to achieve blockbuster status or sweep major awards, it left a lasting impression due to its stellar lead performances and its attempt to bring a historically significant story to the stage. Critics agreed that the show, though flawed, was a worthy effort to honor the legacies of Rubinstein and Arden. Its reception underscores the challenges of adapting complex, real-life figures into musical theater while highlighting the enduring appeal of strong female characters in storytelling.

cypaint

Cast and Crew: Highlighting key performers, directors, and creative team contributions to the production

At the heart of *War Paint*’s Broadway run were its powerhouse leading ladies, Patti LuPone and Christine Ebersole, whose performances as Helena Rubinstein and Elizabeth Arden, respectively, were nothing short of monumental. LuPone brought her signature intensity and vocal prowess to Rubinstein, capturing the character’s fierce ambition and vulnerability. Ebersole, equally commanding, infused Arden with elegance and determination, creating a compelling foil to LuPone’s portrayal. Their chemistry and ability to convey the complex rivalry and camaraderie between these beauty titans were central to the show’s emotional resonance. Both actresses received widespread acclaim, with critics praising their ability to humanize these iconic figures while delivering show-stopping musical numbers.

Directing the production was Michael Greif, a Tony-nominated visionary known for his work on *Rent* and *Dear Evan Hansen*. Greif’s direction was instrumental in balancing the show’s intimate character moments with its grand, operatic scale. He ensured that the rivalry between Rubinstein and Arden remained the focal point, while also allowing the supporting cast to shine. Greif’s collaboration with choreographer Christopher Gattelli added depth to the production, particularly in scenes that used movement to underscore the characters’ inner struggles and external conflicts. Gattelli’s work, though understated, complemented the storytelling without overshadowing the performances.

The creative team behind *War Paint* was equally impressive, with Doug Wright’s book providing a nuanced exploration of the lives and legacies of Rubinstein and Arden. Wright’s script deftly wove historical accuracy with dramatic flair, creating a narrative that was both engaging and thought-provoking. Scott Frankel’s music and Michael Korie’s lyrics, while not universally praised, provided a lush, period-appropriate score that elevated the emotional stakes of the story. The standout numbers, such as *“Back on Top”* and *“Beauty in the World,”* showcased the actresses’ vocal range and the characters’ inner turmoil.

David Korins’ scenic design played a crucial role in transporting audiences to mid-20th-century New York, with sleek, minimalist sets that reflected the characters’ opulent lifestyles. His use of mirrors and reflective surfaces symbolized the duality of beauty and aging, a recurring theme in the show. Costume designer Catherine Zuber earned particular praise for her meticulous recreations of Rubinstein and Arden’s iconic styles, from Rubinstein’s avant-garde ensembles to Arden’s tailored elegance. Zuber’s work not only captured the essence of the characters but also highlighted their contrasting personalities and approaches to business and life.

Finally, the contributions of lighting designer Kenneth Posner and sound designer Brian Ronan cannot be overstated. Posner’s lighting design enhanced the mood of each scene, from the soft glow of Rubinstein’s laboratory to the harsh lights of Arden’s boardroom. Ronan’s sound design ensured that every note and word was crystal clear, allowing the audience to fully immerse themselves in the story. Together, the creative team’s efforts resulted in a production that was visually stunning, musically rich, and thematically profound, even if the show’s overall reception was mixed.

In summary, *War Paint*’s Broadway run was a testament to the talent and dedication of its cast and crew. From the unforgettable performances of LuPone and Ebersole to the meticulous work of the creative team, every element of the production contributed to its impact. While the show may not have achieved the commercial success of some of its contemporaries, its exploration of female ambition, aging, and legacy left a lasting impression on those who experienced it.

cypaint

Audience Feedback: Summarizing viewer reactions, social media buzz, and fan engagement with the show

Viewer reactions to *War Paint* on Broadway have been largely positive, with many praising the show’s powerful storytelling and the commanding performances of its lead actresses. Patti LuPone and Christine Ebersole, who portrayed rival beauty titans Helena Rubinstein and Elizabeth Arden, respectively, have been singled out for their exceptional portrayals. Audience members frequently highlight the emotional depth and historical insight the show provides into the lives of these pioneering women. Reviews often describe the production as "captivating" and "thought-provoking," with particular acclaim for the intricate set design and period-appropriate costumes that transport viewers to mid-20th century New York. However, some attendees have noted that the pacing of the show can feel slow at times, particularly in the first act, which has led to mixed opinions among casual theatergoers.

Social media buzz surrounding *War Paint* has been steady, with fans and critics alike taking to platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok to share their thoughts. Hashtags such as #WarPaintBroadway and #LuPoneEbersole have trended periodically, especially around opening night and during the actresses’ press appearances. Fans have been particularly vocal about the chemistry between LuPone and Ebersole, with many calling their performances "once-in-a-lifetime" and urging others not to miss the show. Memorable moments, such as the show’s climactic duets and the poignant exploration of female rivalry, have been widely shared and discussed. However, some social media users have criticized the show’s marketing for not adequately highlighting its feminist themes, suggesting that a stronger emphasis on this aspect could attract a broader audience.

Fan engagement with *War Paint* extends beyond the theater, with dedicated communities forming online to discuss the show’s historical accuracy, musical numbers, and thematic depth. Forums like Reddit and BroadwayWorld feature threads where enthusiasts dissect the lyrics, debate the characters’ motivations, and share behind-the-scenes trivia. The show’s official merchandise, including programs and cast recordings, has also been popular, with fans expressing appreciation for the high-quality souvenirs. Additionally, post-show talkbacks and Q&A sessions with the cast and creative team have drawn significant interest, providing audiences with deeper insights into the production process and the real-life stories that inspired the musical.

Despite the overall positive reception, some audience members have expressed reservations about the show’s accessibility. A few viewers have noted that the dense dialogue and historical context might alienate those unfamiliar with the lives of Rubinstein and Arden. Others have commented that the lack of a traditional "feel-good" Broadway ending may leave some attendees wanting more. However, these critiques are often balanced by praise for the show’s ambition and its refusal to simplify complex female narratives. The divide in opinions underscores *War Paint*’s appeal to a niche but passionate audience, particularly those interested in biographical dramas and strong female leads.

Overall, *War Paint* has resonated deeply with its target audience, earning a reputation as a must-see for Broadway aficionados and history enthusiasts alike. The show’s ability to spark conversations about gender, ambition, and legacy has been a significant factor in its success, with many viewers leaving the theater inspired and moved. While it may not have achieved the mainstream popularity of some other Broadway productions, *War Paint* has carved out a unique space for itself, celebrated for its artistry, performances, and the important stories it brings to life. As the show continues its run, its impact on both audiences and the broader theatrical community remains a topic of enthusiastic discussion.

cypaint

Comparative Success: Comparing War Paint’s run to similar Broadway productions in its genre

War Paint, the 2017 Broadway musical chronicling the rivalry between cosmetics titans Helena Rubinstein and Elizabeth Arden, has carved a distinct niche in the musical theater landscape. While it did not achieve the blockbuster status of juggernauts like Hamilton or The Lion King, its success is best understood in comparison to similar productions within its genre: biographical musicals centered on historical figures. Unlike Beautiful: The Carole King Musical or Jersey Boys, which leaned on well-known song catalogs, War Paint featured an original score by Scott Frankel and Michael Korie, a riskier proposition that limited its mainstream appeal but earned critical acclaim for its sophistication. Its 269-performance run, while modest by Broadway standards, aligns with the trajectory of other biographical musicals that prioritize artistic integrity over commercialism, such as Grey Gardens (2006), which ran for 307 performances despite its similarly niche subject matter.

When compared to *The Cher Show* (2018), another biographical musical about a female icon, *War Paint* stands out for its dramatic depth and thematic complexity. While *The Cher Show* capitalized on Cher’s pop culture ubiquity and a jukebox format to achieve 369 performances, *War Paint* focused on the psychological and professional rivalry between its subjects, appealing more to theater aficionados than casual audiences. Similarly, *War Paint* outperformed *Chaplin: The Musical* (2012), which closed after just 30 previews and 136 regular performances, demonstrating that its strong book, direction, and star power (Christine Ebersole and Patti LuPone) provided a more solid foundation for longevity.

In the realm of female-centric biographical musicals, *War Paint* also holds its own against *Gloria: A Life* (2018), a play about Gloria Steinem that ran for 125 performances. While *Gloria* relied on a non-musical format and a more straightforward narrative, *War Paint*’s musicalization of its story added emotional depth and theatricality, likely contributing to its longer run. However, it fell short of *Come from Away* (2017), which, though not strictly biographical, shares thematic elements of resilience and human connection. *Come from Away*’s universal appeal and ensemble storytelling propelled it to over 2,500 performances, highlighting the challenge *War Paint* faced in balancing specificity with broad audience engagement.

Financially, *War Paint*’s success is nuanced. While it did not recoup its $14 million capitalization, it maintained a respectable average ticket price and weekly gross, often exceeding 70% of its potential gross. This places it ahead of *The Scottsboro Boys* (2010), another Frankel-Korie collaboration that closed after just 49 performances despite critical praise. However, it lagged behind *Kinky Boots* (2013), which ran for 2,507 performances and recouped its investment within nine months, underscoring the commercial advantage of feel-good narratives and Cyndi Lauper’s pop score.

Ultimately, *War Paint*’s success lies in its artistic achievements rather than box office dominance. Its Tony Award nominations, including Best Actress for both leads, solidified its place as a critically respected production. When compared to its genre peers, *War Paint* emerges as a middle-tier success—not a runaway hit, but a meaningful contribution to Broadway’s biographical musical canon. Its run reflects the challenges of balancing historical accuracy, artistic ambition, and audience accessibility, making it a valuable case study for future productions in this genre.

Frequently asked questions

War Paint opened on Broadway on April 6, 2017, and closed on November 5, 2017, running for approximately 7 months.

The leading roles of Helena Rubinstein and Elizabeth Arden were played by Patti LuPone and Christine Ebersole, respectively.

Yes, War Paint received four Tony Award nominations in 2017, including Best Actress in a Musical for both Patti LuPone and Christine Ebersole.

War Paint received generally positive reviews, with particular praise for the performances of LuPone and Ebersole, though some critics noted the show's pacing and script as areas for improvement.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment