Lena Rivera
When it comes to painting projects, the paint brand can significantly impact the outcome. Two of the most popular paint companies are Dunn Edwards and Sherwin Williams, with both offering durable and thick paints with good hide and warranties. Sherwin Williams has a more recognisable brand and has been delivering products for over 150 years. However, Dunn Edwards, a 92-year-old company, has been celebrated for its durability and is the preferred option for many high-quality painters.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Durability | Both brands are durable, but Sherwin Williams has better resistance to staining, fading, and damage due to its special polymer formula. Dunn Edwards is also durable and has a warranty. |
| Ease of Application | Sherwin Williams is favoured by contractors due to its ease of application. Dunn Edwards paint is watery and splotchy, requiring two coats and a sprayer. |
| Colour Range | Sherwin Williams has a wider range of colours with more complex undertones. |
| Brand Recognition | Sherwin Williams is a more recognisable brand worldwide. |
| SCAQMD Compliance | Sherwin Williams has invested in making all its paints SCAQMD-compliant. Dunn Edwards historically catered to SCAQMD rules but this may have changed with new ownership. |
| Temperature Application | Dunn Edwards Spartawall paints should not be applied below 50°F, while Sherwin Williams Super Paint can be used at temperatures as low as 35°F. |
| Warranty | Dunn Edwards offers a "Lifetime" warranty, but it may depend on the use of a primer. Sherwin Williams' warranty does not mention primer. |
Explore related products
Durability
When it comes to durability, both Dunn Edwards and Sherwin Williams are leading paint brands that offer high-quality, long-lasting products. However, there are some differences in their durability features that are worth noting.
Dunn Edwards paints are known for their durability, making them suitable for various applications. Their product line includes Evershield, a well-liked option that comes with a warranty. The paint is designed to be durable, and the company offers a ""Lifetime" warranty, although some users have noted that the company often attributes premature failure to applicator error. The paint applies smoothly and dries quickly, providing an even finish. It is also thicker than many other popular brands, contributing to its durability.
On the other hand, Sherwin Williams stands out for its special polymer formula, which offers excellent resistance to staining, fading, and damage. Their SuperPaint line, in particular, is highly durable and can be scrubbed without leaving traces of dirt. It also maintains its sheen and consistency. Sherwin Williams' paint also has impressive adhesion, colour retention, and hide, thanks to their Advanced Resin Technology. Additionally, their Duration Home paint is also well-regarded for its durability.
While both brands offer excellent durability, Sherwin Williams may have a slight edge due to its advanced formulas and technologies, providing superior resistance to staining, fading, and damage. However, Dunn Edwards remains a highly durable option, especially with its Evershield line, and offers the added reassurance of a warranty.
In terms of real-world performance, some users have reported that Dunn Edwards paint can start to fade within a couple of years, leading to requests for repainting. In contrast, Sherwin Williams' paint has been observed to hold up extremely well over time, even after more than 20 years.
Bake Your Painting with Twist Glass: A Step-by-Step Guide
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Ease of application
When it comes to ease of application, both Dunn Edwards and Sherwin Williams have their unique strengths. Dunn Edwards paints are known for their smooth application, quick drying times, and even finish. Its Spartashield paint, for instance, has an average drying time of 1-2 hours and can be recoated in 4-6 hours, depending on humidity. The paint can be applied at temperatures as low as 35°F, providing flexibility for different climates.
On the other hand, Sherwin Williams is a preferred choice for contractors due to its durability and ease of application. Their SuperPaint line, for instance, is highly durable and can be scrubbed without leaving traces of dirt, maintaining its sheen and consistency. Sherwin Williams' paint also features Advanced Resin Technology, ensuring impressive adhesion and colour retention.
While both brands offer warranties, there are some differences in their approaches. Dunn Edwards offers a "Lifetime" warranty, but some users have noted that it only applies if a primer is used, and the company may attribute claims to applicator error. Sherwin Williams also offers a warranty, which some users have found more straightforward to claim, even when applying the paint themselves.
In terms of colour options, Sherwin Williams offers a wide range of colours with complex undertones, allowing for more nuanced colour choices.
Both brands have their advantages in terms of ease of application. Dunn Edwards' quick drying times and temperature flexibility can be advantageous for timely and versatile projects, while Sherwin Williams' durability and adhesion may be preferred for projects requiring long-lasting results and ease of maintenance.
Choosing the Right Paint for Your 2018 Avalanche
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Warranty
When it comes to warranties, both Dunn Edwards and Sherwin Williams offer certain guarantees for their products. Dunn Edwards provides a "Lifetime" warranty on their paints, although some users have noted that this warranty only applies if a primer is used. On the other hand, Sherwin Williams offers a limited lifetime warranty for as long as the customer lives in their home. This warranty does not explicitly mention the use of a primer.
Dunn Edwards' Evershield paint, in particular, is known to have a warranty of 7 years when applied to wood trim and 10 years when used on stucco. This warranty may be a significant factor for some customers, as it provides a longer guarantee for the paint's durability and performance.
In terms of durability, both brands are known to offer high-quality, durable paints. Sherwin Williams, however, has an edge due to its special polymer formula, which provides excellent resistance against staining, fading, and damage. Their paints are designed to be peel-resistant, blister-resistant, and crack-resistant, ensuring the longevity of painted surfaces.
On the other hand, some users have reported issues with Dunn Edwards' paint fading prematurely. While their paints are generally considered durable, there have been instances where repainting was required sooner than expected. This may be a factor to consider when choosing between the two brands, especially if long-term performance is a priority.
It is worth noting that the experience with paint warranties may vary. Some users have shared positive experiences with Sherwin Williams' warranty, while others have mentioned that Dunn Edwards tends to shift the blame to applicator error when issues arise. Ultimately, the installer's warranty and their longevity in the business may be more important factors to consider in addition to the paint warranty itself.
Edible Gold: Painting Cakes with Style
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Brand recognition
When it comes to brand recognition, Sherwin Williams has a clear edge over Dunn Edwards. Sherwin Williams is a highly recognisable brand, not only within the paint industry but also globally. On the other hand, Dunn Edwards is a well-known company within the industry, but it does not have the same level of brand recognition as Sherwin Williams.
Dunn Edwards, an employee-owned company based in Los Angeles, California, has a 92-year history of catering to the more challenging SCAQMD rules. The company's paints are known for their durability and are widely used in various applications. Their product range includes the popular Evershield line, and they offer warranties on their paints.
Sherwin Williams, founded in 1866, is a leading paint manufacturer with a strong brand presence. The company has been delivering top-tier products for over 150 years and is trusted by contractors and consumers alike. Their paints are known for their durability, ease of application, and special polymer formula, which provides excellent resistance to staining, fading, and damage. Sherwin Williams' mid-level brand, SuperPaint, is highly durable and known for its scrubability without compromising the sheen and consistency of the paint.
Both brands offer high-quality paints, but Sherwin Williams has a stronger brand presence and is more recognisable to consumers. Dunn Edwards is a reputable company with a strong industry presence, but it may not have the same level of brand recognition among the general public. Ultimately, both brands have their own advantages and loyal customer bases, but Sherwin Williams takes the lead in terms of brand recognition and awareness.
The Best Time to Buff Out After Auto Painting
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Cost-effectiveness
When it comes to cost-effectiveness, Dunn-Edwards and Sherwin-Williams offer different advantages. Dunn-Edwards, a 92-year-old company based in Los Angeles, is known for its responsive customer service and contractor relationships. Their paints are durable, with good coverage and hide, and they offer a warranty on their products. On the other hand, Sherwin-Williams is a highly recognizable, leading paint manufacturer with a global presence. They have been in the industry for over 150 years, offering a wide range of interior and exterior paints, stains, and primers for various projects.
Dunn-Edwards provides a "Lifetime" warranty on their paints, but it is conditional upon the use of a primer, which some may consider an additional expense. Their paints are also known to be cost-effective, durable, and smooth-spreading, making them a preferred choice for many contractors. The company has recently expanded its compliance with SCAQMD rules, ensuring consistent product quality across all areas.
Sherwin-Williams, on the other hand, offers a strong warranty without explicitly requiring the use of a primer. Their paints are known for their durability, ease of application, and special polymer formula, providing excellent resistance to staining, fading, and damage. Their SuperPaint line, in particular, stands out for its scrubability without compromising the sheen and consistency of the paint.
Both companies offer unique advantages in terms of cost-effectiveness. While Dunn-Edwards may be more affordable upfront and has responsive customer service, Sherwin-Williams' long-lasting durability and robust warranty could potentially save customers money in the long run by reducing the need for frequent repainting, as evidenced by anecdotes of Dunn-Edwards paint fading or not holding up over time. Ultimately, the decision between the two brands depends on specific project needs, budget constraints, and personal preferences.
Merging Krita Masterpieces: Combining Two Paintings Seamlessly
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Both brands are known for their durability. Sherwin Williams gains an edge with its special polymer formula, providing excellent resistance against staining, fading, and damage. For long-lasting results, Sherwin Williams is the top pick. Dunn Edwards is also durable and offers a warranty on its paints.
Dunn Edwards paints apply smoothly, dry quickly, and provide an even finish. Sherwin Williams is also known for its ease of application and is used by contractors.
Sherwin Williams is a more recognisable and synonymous brand in the paint industry. Dunn Edwards is known within the industry but not to the same extent as Sherwin Williams. Sherwin Williams has also been around for longer, having delivered top-tier products for over 150 years. The brand also has a wider range of colours due to the complexity of their undertones. Dunn Edwards, on the other hand, has a lower temperature threshold for its Spartawall paint and is more cost-effective.
